|
"DIGITAL envelopes, DIGITAL LFO's!!!!!!!!!!!! No wonder it don't sound as good as the classics. Not analog, not even VA or digital, the andromeda is lost in a realm of mediocrity."
This is utterly idiotic. Except for a Buchla I can't name a single analog envelope that's more than an ADSR. So if you want anything remotely versitile or interesting, digital is the only way to go. And about every "analog" synth since the early 80's has digital envelopes and LFOs (including the MKS70 which you reccomended), most of those being 8-bit. I'm not absolutely certain but I'd imagine the modulation on the Andromeda is calculated to at least 16-bits, alleviating the stepping problem present on older analogs (which strangely enough seem to be perfectly useable despite being terribly crippled by digital modulation). I have serious doubts as to whether an analog envelope would sound any different (nevermind any better) than a well-coded digital envelope. Envelopes and LFOs only affect a sound indirectly, so the affects are much less audible than the difference between analog and digital oscillators, etc. I think any difference in sound would only be detected by careful analysis, and even then I doubt one would sound any better than the other.
Step off your stupid analog elitist platform and look at the whole synth, not the individual parts. One could just as easily say that the SH-09, OB8, and MKS70 are awful and useless awful because they don't use integrated circuits in the signal path, or because they're not Minimoogs or TR-909s or because they don't have holographic paint jobs. And their opinion wouldn't be any more justified.
And this bit just kills me:
"just traded it for a triton cause the triton soudns sat better in my mix, and i hate digital."
has the irony of this sunk in yet? Surprise! The Triton has digital envelopes and LFOs! In fact, it's ALL DIGITAL. So it must be the worst synth in the world!
|