|
If you are a professional musician (make your leaving playing music) you're probably not reading this. I am a professional computer programmer and, first of all, I don't usually need other people opinion in my area of expertise, and second of all I never consider the cost as a factor when I'm buying the tool I make money with... With that in mind here goes the review. QS8 is cheep, that's the main reason we're even talking about it. But that's off course not the only reason. I'll be comparing QS8 to its main competitor - N1. The keyboard is FATAR - better than Korg's, a little lighter (preferred by some) and less noisy. Banks/Patches/Mixes organization is a lot better on QS8, but if you're not a complete idiot, Korg's is not so horrible either. But maybe, first I should tell you my story. I bought QS7 first and I loved it. Then I decided that 88 weighted keys is a must for me and I exchanged it for N1 (why N1 and not QS8? Just wanted to try something else..). The Korg I bought had these disgusting mahogany wooden ends that made it look like a piece of furniture so I had to return it. Unfortunately, they didn't have any other N1's and I decided to buy FATAR Studiologic controller and a sound module. Now, take it from me, do not buy Studiologic! These guys make pretty nice keys but their controllers suck big time! I opened one and, Mamma Mia, what did I see inside... There're some nice shoes they make in Italy but not controllers - what a piece of crap! Cheap, cheap, cheap! Well, I didn't have any choice and I bought QS8 (I wanted to buy something already!) Now, I recorded a few sequences using QS7 presets and then recorded the same sequences using N1. The difference: N1 wins 10 to zero. Full bodied, convincing sounds versus very thin mix of 'noises' with each individual sound loosing it's personality in a mix completely. I've listened for those sequences through my JBL at home, through my really crappy car stereo - same result. Don't get me wrong, QS's sound was OK, but only before I compared it to Korg's. It's like listening for something without the right EQ setup or with one, you never know before you compare!!! OK, so you're probably thinking that I'm totally in love with Korg now, right? Wrong! If choosing a synth was so easy, this site wouldn't even exist! I was looking for all around keyboard. The one that can provide me with, maybe, not all the best features but with a lot of them. So let's compare, shell we? As being said before, Korg beats Alesis in the sound department, especially in the multitimbral mode. Setting up a multi mode is a different story altogether though. You just have to love Alesis's Mix mode, so easy! You can assign any patch to any of the 16 MIDI channels in a matter of a seconds. Korg, well, only GM/GS/XG are easy, custom config is a nightmare if possible at all. Piano sounds, ah those pianos! My first impression was that the QS is better, but after listening for some piano solos produced by both, I must say that Korg is better again. Just compare the high notes and you'll see what I'm talking about. Winds (especially flute and sax) - very nice on QS8. But with Korg you get breath (press a key a little harder) and a lip (press it a little more harder). Acoustic Guitars - QS8 no doubt. Korg sucks, (but not too much). Srings: QS8 - UNUSABLE!!!, Korg - beautiful. Synth: very creative on QS but, again mostly unusable even if you're into Vangelis kind of thing. Korg - classy, a little boring at times but a step above in terms of quality and frankly (my opinion) a lot more inspirational. Drums: ah what the hell, Alesis just can not win! Let's talk about QS's winning points, cause there're some more actually. It fits in 76 key case (important to some of us). It has two PCMCI slots (not bad but who cares considering the price of the blank cards - 60 bucks for an 8meg aftermarket card without guarantee to work and $110 for a real one? please. Q-cards did not impress me al all based on the demo). No power supply, just plug it into the outlet (I like this, make me feel comfortable..). Metal all around ( Korg has this nasty wooden/paper/carton like bottom panel, horrible!). That's about it. You may ask me "What about other products?". Well, the way I see it, there's nothing really else in this category. A90/PC88/SgPro are all controllers. Just a few sounds and a LOT of buttons. Unless you're a life performing musician, those things will be useless to you. Besides, the price of these controllers is equal or higher than of those you'd pay for QS8 or N1. As for the keys, PC88 uses the same FATAR keys as QS8, SgPro - same as N1, and A90 - who cares, it's so expensive anyway (and not better at all). Off course we have Z1/Trinity, EX5/7, XP, JP8000, Nord, Ensoniq stuff, but those are synths/workstation and I believe we're talking about Piano action here plus Synth, so those can not be really applied here. Bottom line: QS8, N1 or else.... For a home studio, QS8 is very good as a controller with some free sounds and a good platform to do some basic home-brew sequencing. N1 is equally a good controller with a lot better sounds but a pain in the neck as a multitimbral sound module. The way I see it, if you're like me and never satisfied with anything (like most musicians I might add) then bite the bullet and buy everything out there! Finding a happy medium is impossible. A nice 88-key controller (QS8 will do BTW), 61-key synth action controller (can't leave without it either), a few sound modules (which you'll keep buying and buying and buying.....) is all you need, so think realistically what you need at this time then just go and buy it , that's all.
|